Biodegradable Packaging: Myths vs. Facts

As the world becomes more environmentally aware, the demand for eco-friendly packaging solutions has significantly increased. People are looking for ways to reduce their carbon footprint, and packaging is often seen as a good place to start. With terms like biodegradable, compostable, and green packaging being used frequently, understanding the nuances and truths behind these terms is essential. Our goal with this blog post is to elucidate common biodegradable packaging myths and provide clarity, thereby helping you make more informed decisions about packaging options.

To navigate the world of sustainable packaging, it is crucial to understand the terminology and what it really implies.

At its core, biodegradable packaging is designed to decompose over time through the action of microorganisms such as bacteria and fungi, returning to natural base elements like water, carbon dioxide, and biomass. However, the term biodegradable doesn't specify how quickly this breakdown occurs or whether harmful residues are left behind. These aspects depend significantly on environmental factors and the material's composition.

A subset of biodegradable materials, compostable packaging breaks down under specific conditions, typically in industrial composting facilities. These conditions include specific temperature, moisture, and microbial activity levels. The process results in nutrient-rich compost, free of toxic residues. International standards such as EN 13432 and ASTM D6400 govern the certification of compostable packaging to ensure they meet stringent requirements for safe decomposition.

These are broad terms that encompass packaging solutions aiming to minimize environmental impact. This type of packaging often uses renewable or recycled materials and considers the environmental impact throughout its lifecycle—from production and transportation to use and disposal. It's important to note that not all biodegradable packaging is eco-friendly. Choosing the right packaging requires a comprehensive life-cycle assessment to ensure it aligns with sustainable practices and truly minimizes environmental harm.

Understanding these distinctions lets businesses and consumers make informed choices beyond the enticing marketing claims that simplify these complexities into mere buzzwords.

While biodegradable packaging might sound environmentally friendly, it isn't inherently superior in all contexts. The benefits, and pitfalls, of biodegradable materials largely depend on how they are used and the conditions they face at the end of their life. For instance, some biodegradable plastics, known as oxo-degradable plastics, contain additives that cause them to fragment into microplastics, which can persist in the environment and enter the food chain.

Moreover, if biodegradable materials end up in landfills, they might decompose without the presence of oxygen, a process that generates methane—a potent greenhouse gas. The environmental impact may be further compounded by the energy-intensive processes required to produce some biodegradable materials, which can also involve significant land and water use.

Thus, a biodegradable label does not automatically translate to being environmentally friendly. The sustainability of packaging is not solely determined by its material but by its life-cycle impact.

The belief that all biodegradable packaging quickly decomposes is a misconception. The term "biodegradable" lacks specific timelines and conditions required for breakdown. Many biodegradable plastics, such as PLA (polylactic acid), necessitate industrial composting facilities where precise conditions—temperature and microbial presence—are maintained. Without such facilities, biodegradable packages might linger as long as conventional plastics in landfills or even home composts.

Moreover, unless compostable packaging is accompanied by proper infrastructure, such as industrial composting systems, the benefits of biodegradability cannot be realized. The reality is that biodegradable packaging might often remain intact for extended periods if conditions aren't optimal, which influences its practical value in waste reduction initiatives.

A common misconception is that these two terms can be used interchangeably. All compostable materials are biodegradable, but not all biodegradable materials are compostable. Compostable packaging is distinguished by the requirement to decompose into natural elements quickly under specific composting conditions without leaving harmful residues. Biodegradable products, however, may not meet these rigorous standards and could leave behind microplastics.

Certified compostable materials are subject to strict testing to ensure they disintegrate within defined time frames and do not pose any eco-toxicity. In contrast, products labeled simply as biodegradable may not meet such criteria, leading to confusion about their environmental friendliness.

Understanding the reality of sustainable packaging involves acknowledging some crucial facts:

• Not all "eco" packaging is chemical-free: Some sustainable options, including biodegradable and paper-based packaging, may contain coatings or additives that include harmful substances like PFAS (per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances) or BPA (Bisphenol A).
• Bio-based does not always mean compostable: Bioplastics refer to materials that are bio-based, biodegradable, or both. However, some bio-based plastics, like polyethylene terephthalate (PET), remain structurally similar to their fossil-based counterparts and lack biodegradability. Conversely, certain fossil-based materials are engineered to be compostable.
• Life-cycle assessments are crucial: Thorough assessments help understand the impact of packaging beyond its biodegradability. By looking at the entire life cycle, from resource extraction to disposal, businesses can choose options that substantially reduce waste and improve sustainability metrics like carbon and water footprints.
• Infrastructure and behavior are critical: Eco-friendly packaging relies on proper infrastructure for recycling and composting and informed consumer behavior. Even the most sustainably designed packaging fails in its purpose if waste management systems or consumer disposal practices do not support it.

To truly understand sustainable packaging, a multi-dimensional approach that considers all these factors is required, surpassing reliance on single-criteria claims of eco-friendliness.

For both businesses and consumers, making informed choices about eco-friendly packaging demands a closer look at industry standards, certification, and local waste management systems.

• Match materials to product needs: Packaging integrity is essential to prevent spoilage. While biodegradable packaging is beneficial, it might not provide the necessary protection for certain products, leading to wastage.
• Verify certifications over mere claims: Look for certifications like EN 13432 or ASTM D6400 that verify the compostability of packaging. Such certifications signal adherence to stringent environmental safety and performance standards.
• Evaluate chemical use: Businesses need to inquire about potentially harmful chemicals within packaging products, ensuring they align with environmental and health priorities.
• Assess local waste capabilities: Understanding local waste management infrastructure can influence what types of eco-friendly packaging are viable, particularly whether industrial composting facilities are accessible.

• Look beyond buzzwords: Consumers should scrutinize packaging labels and verify claims of being 'eco' or 'biodegradable' by checking for certifications and additional details.
• Follow disposal instructions: Proper disposal is vital for maximizing the environmental benefits of eco-friendly packaging. Ensuring materials reach the appropriate waste streams—whether for recycling or composting—is essential.
• Avoid contaminating recycling: Commingling biodegradable materials with regular recycling can hinder the process, making it crucial to adhere to disposal guidelines to prevent contamination.
• Prioritize reducing and reusing materials: Consider whether packaging can be reduced or reused before disposal. By minimizing packaging wherever possible, environmental impacts become significantly reduced.

Unraveling the biodegradable packaging myths provides a window into making sustainable choices grounded in fact, not marketing hype. Not all biodegradable packaging is rapid, compostable, or free of environmental concerns, and alternatives may provide greater sustainability benefits when assessed holistically.

Focusing on life-cycle impacts, certification, and synergy with waste systems, businesses and consumers can pursue truly eco-friendly packaging that benefits people and the planet.

We invite you to engage in the conversation: have you encountered biodegradable or compostable packaging—either in business or as a consumer? What experiences have guided your packaging choices? Share stories and thoughts in the comments.

Stay informed by subscribing to our blog for ongoing insights into sustainable packaging and practical eco-friendly practices that drive positive change for our environment.